Colossians 3:16
Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly in all wisdom; teaching and admonishing one another in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, singing with grace in your hearts to the Lord.
There is something powerful that happens when a congregation sings together.
But not all songs do that well. And that is worth thinking about.
This is not an argument for one style over another. It is not a case for the old against the new, or the traditional against the contemporary. It is simply an invitation to take seriously what Paul told the church at Colossae, that the songs we sing are meant to let the word of Christ dwell in us richly.
The question worth asking is not how old is this song?
It is how much of Christ is in it?
God's Design for Congregational Singing
Paul's instruction in Ephesians 5:19 gives us a remarkably broad category for worship music, “Speaking to yourselves in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, singing and making melody in your heart to the Lord.”
That breadth is intentional.
Congregational singing should not be confined to a single style, era, or form. It should be rich, varied, and full, much like the Psalms themselves, which range from triumphant praise to gut-honest lament, from quiet trust to thunderous declaration.
What unifies that variety is not style.
It is substance.
Every psalm, every hymn, every spiritual song is meant to carry the weight of truth and direct the heart toward God. When a song does that well, whatever its form, it belongs in the worship of God's people.
What Great Songs Do
Whether a song was written in the eighteenth century or last year, the best worship songs share certain qualities. They are worth looking for, and worth protecting.
1) They are anchored in Scripture.
The greatest songs the church has ever sung draw their content from the Word of God. They are not vague impressions about a generic higher power. They are specific declarations about the God of the Bible, the cross of Christ, the grace that saves, the hope that holds. When a song is saturated with Scripture, it does more than entertain.
It instructs.
2) They teach as they are sung.
Paul connects singing directly to teaching and admonishing one another in Colossians 3:16. That means congregational singing is not a passive experience. It is a corporate act of edification.
When the words are theologically grounded, the congregation is being built up every time they sing them, whether they realize it or not.
3) They engage both the heart and the mind.
Paul's standard in 1 Corinthians 14:15 is clear, “I will sing with the spirit, and I will sing with the understanding also.”
The best songs stir genuine emotion because they are rooted in genuine truth. Feeling and doctrine are not enemies in worship.
They are meant to travel together.
4) They point to Christ, not to the experience of worship itself.
There is a subtle but important difference between a song that says look at what God has done and one that says look at how I feel about God.
Both have their place. But a steady diet of the latter can quietly shift the center of worship from the Savior to the worshipper. Songs that keep Christ at the center, His person, His work, His glory, do the most lasting good.
The Gift of the Historic Hymns
It would be a real loss to walk away from the great hymns of the faith, not because they are old, but because they are extraordinarily good at doing what congregational singing is meant to do.
The men and women who wrote them were not simply poets. They were theologians with a pastoral burden.
- Isaac Watts wanted truth to be singable.
- Charles Wesley believed every doctrine deserved to be sung.
- Fanny Crosby, blind from infancy, wrote thousands of hymns because she had seen something with the eyes of faith that she could not stop putting into words.
Open a hymn like And Can It Be and you will find the incarnation, the atonement, the new birth, and the assurance of salvation — all developed across five stanzas.
Sing It Is Well With My Soul and you are singing words written by a man who had just lost his four daughters at sea. Those words have steadied grieving believers ever since, because they were already planted in the memory, already true.
That kind of depth is a gift. And it is a gift worth passing on to the next generation, not as a museum piece, but as a living inheritance.
The Value of Newer Songs
At the same time, God has not stopped inspiring His people to write.
There are songs being sung today that are rich in doctrine, saturated in Scripture, and genuinely Christ-centered. When a newer song meets that standard, it deserves a place in our worship just as much as any hymn written centuries ago.
The issue was never the age of the song.
The issue is always the content.
A theologically empty hymn from 1750 does less for the congregation than a doctrinally rich song written last decade. What we are after is not the preservation of an era, it is the presence of truth.
Why Balance Matters
A healthy worship diet includes both old and new, and here is why:
The older songs anchor us. They connect us to the faith of a long line of believers who trusted the same God before us. They remind us that we did not invent this faith, we received it.
The newer songs remind us the gospel is still alive. They reflect a faith that is not frozen in the past but active in the present, still moving hearts, still producing fruit, still being proclaimed in every generation.
Together, they give the congregation something full and balanced, a worship life that is rooted in history and alive in the present.
Singing With Understanding
When the lyrics appear on the screen, resist the urge to simply wait for the music to cue you in.
Read the words first.
Let them land as statements of faith before they become songs of worship. Ask yourself:
- What is this saying about God?
- Do I believe this?
- What is this calling me to remember or do?
That simple habit turns singing from a passive activity into an act of genuine, engaged worship, which is exactly what God is after.
John 4:24
God is a Spirit: and they that worship him must worship him in spirit and in truth.
A Word Before You Leave Your Seat
The songs we sing together are not filler between the announcements and the sermon.
They are a vital part of what happens when the church gathers. They teach us. They anchor us. They give us a shared language for expressing faith, grief, hope, and praise. They plant truth in us that surfaces at exactly the right moment, in a hospital room, in a sleepless night, when we need it most.
So sing.
Sing the old songs and mean them.
Sing the newer songs and let them do their work.
Sing with your whole heart and your whole mind.
And let the word of Christ dwell in you richly, not just while the music plays, but long after you leave your seat.
1 Corinthians 14:15
I will sing with the spirit, and I will sing with the understanding also.
At Faith Baptist Church, we are committed to worship that is rooted in Scripture, balanced in expression, and directed wholly to the glory of God — because the songs we sing shape what we believe.







